Area libraries seek lifeline from state as project costs escalate

  • The Tilton Library on North Main Street in South Deerfield. STAFF FILE PHOTO/CHRIS LARABEE

  • Patrons enter the Jones Library in Amherst. Staff File Photo

  • Library Director Jessica Magelaner looks down at the crowded stacks in the Wheeler Memorial Library in Orange. Staff File Photo/Paul Franz

Staff Writer
Published: 8/19/2022 5:31:25 PM
Modified: 8/19/2022 5:27:58 PM

SOUTH DEERFIELD — In a bid to secure more American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) money for pandemic-induced cost increases, Deerfield, along with Amherst, Orange and five other Massachusetts towns, has sent a letter to Gov. Charlie Baker and to Senate and House leaders appealing for state relief.

In July, Deerfield, Orange, Gloucester, Grafton, Seekonk, Westborough and Westford were awarded Massachusetts Board of Library Commissioners (MBLC) grants to fund their library projects. However, the grant process requires libraries to apply for the grant years in advance, setting an award in stone, which means unexpected cost changes — especially those caused by the COVID-19 pandemic — are not accounted for. Amherst accepted its library grant in 2021, but inflation has ballooned renovation costs for the Jones Library by more than $11 million.

“Here in Deerfield, we were ecstatic to receive the news that our grant application proposal — submitted in 2017 before the COVID-19 pandemic upended all of our lives — had finally been approved. It was to pay about half the cost of the project,” the Deerfield Selectboard’s letter reads. “But Deerfield’s euphoria (and that of our fellow communities) has quickly faded. We have collectively experienced sticker shock upon examining the true post-COVID costs of building our library projects.”

Deerfield Selectboard member Tim Hilchey said the letter is an opportunity to illustrate that communities across Massachusetts are being hit by these cost increases, and with a supplemental budget expected to pass this fall, it’s a chance to dole out more ARPA money that the federal government may “claw back” if it’s not spent.

“It’s obvious that all eight of these communities are going to have a hard time making up the inflationary post-COVID price increases,” Hilchey said by phone. “These cost increases are directly related to COVID and that’s what ARPA is for.”

Hilchey said he and fellow Selectboard member Carolyn Shores Ness called the other six towns in this year’s round of Massachusetts Board of Library Commissioners grants — Amherst reached out to Deerfield — and asked if they’d join in on the letter.

“They’re all happy to participate in this effort,” Hilchey said. “All of the towns expressed interest in receiving more money and we hope that we can reach the governor in a timely fashion.”

Austin Sarat, president of Amherst’s Jones Library’s board of trustees, said Deerfield’s letter “states the problem quite accurately and identifies a way of dealing with the problem.” The Jones Library’s hard costs, including construction of the building and landscaping, were pegged at $26.9 million when the project was approved; those costs are now estimated at $38.5 million, if the project breaks ground in October 2023.

“This is not simply a problem of this town or that town. It affects many towns,” Sarat said. “Certainly the experience in Amherst is exactly what was described. The question is how can we deal with those escalating costs. … (Deerfield) has put the ball in play, to use a sports metaphor.”

The Jones Library submitted its grant application in 2016 and the library was awarded a $13.87 million provisional grant in May 2021. With the price increases, Sarat said the library’s board of trustees and the town will need to “enter into a set of conversations” about what their options are for funding at this point in the project, which is “finishing the schematic design phase.”

Options, he continued, could entail a bigger fundraising push from the library, an increased contribution from the town or reducing parts of the project.

“No reduction of the cost of the building,” Sarat said, “is going to cover that escalation of cost.”

In Westford, J.V. Fletcher Library Director Ellen Rainville said the library has not gotten its new cost estimate yet, but its original cost estimate was $21.4 million and she is now expecting a $30 million project. The town also received its grant a year early because the state released more funds to the Massachusetts Board of Library Commissioners.

“We are playing catch-up and are very dependent on the bids, cost estimates and escalating price tags that we see our sister libraries gleaning, as they’re ahead of us in our project planning,” Rainville said. “We have every incentive to collaborate with our sister libraries, who are also hoping to move their projects forward and to bring funds that are needed in every community.”

In the letter to the governor, Deerfield presents the importance of a community’s library, referencing Andrew Carnegie’s famous description of a library as a “never-failing spring.”

“Gov. Baker and Lt. Gov. (Karyn) Polito, this is a generation opportunity to help nurture a ‘never-failing spring’ in each of these communities,” Deerfield’s letter reads. “We ask that you hear our plea and provide additional ARPA funds to our communities. We will use them in the spirit for which they were intended.”

For Rainville, these eight libraries working together is the essence of everything libraries stand for.

“Libraries are about sharing. We’re sharing information, we’re sharing need,” she said. “The commonwealth evidently has much more revenue than anticipated. … It would be great to use those to benefit every member of the community.”

While Amherst is currently in the design process, the seven towns in this year’s grant round have six months to match the grant, otherwise it is lost and the towns must start over. In Deerfield, residents will have a chance to decide on borrowing money for the Tilton Library’s project at an October Special Town Meeting and possibly during an election in November.

“We’ll see what the voters decide,” Hilchey said. “We need to attract more young people and young families to the community, and one way to do that is to have high-quality institutions like libraries.”

Chris Larabee can be reached at or 413-930-4081.


Support Local Journalism

Subscribe to the Greenfield Recorder, keeping Franklin County informed since 1792.

Greenfield Recorder

14 Hope Street
Greenfield, MA 01302-1367
Phone: (413) 772-0261


Copyright © 2021 by Newspapers of Massachusetts, Inc.
Terms & Conditions - Privacy Policy