Report outlines disparities in telehealth: Seniors, children and those living in rural areas less likely to use the service

For the Recorder
Published: 12/9/2022 5:27:43 PM

With an unprecedented uptick in mental illnesses amplified by the COVID-19 pandemic and its subsequent lockdowns, telehealth usage spiked when in-person care was unavailable. But new research from the Harvard Pilgrim Health Care Institute shows a disparity in access to telehealth services among different populations across Massachusetts.

The report, commissioned by the Massachusetts Association of Health Plans and Massachusetts Health Quality Partners, highlights the “digital divide,” defined as the interconnected variations in population related to who has the access to tech devices, digital literacy, financial means for broadband internet and reliable internet infrastructure.

Researchers found that those of lower socioeconomic status — seniors, children and those living in rural areas — are less likely to use telehealth services. People facing financial difficulties, often communities of color who may also require translation, have more difficulty getting the technology needed to receive proper care. Seniors are less likely to have the digital literacy skills to use telehealth properly, and those residing in rural areas may not have the proper internet infrastructure.

Dr. Alan Peltz, lead researcher on the report and assistant professor at the Department of Population Medicine at Harvard Medical School, said he and his team of researchers were aware of the long-standing divide in internet access pre-pandemic and wanted to see how that manifested in health care services. The study’s findings confirmed earlier suspicions, he said, but still brought forth some shocking results.

“One of the things that were surprising to us all was that even after 2020, when life became so tied to virtual digital connection, the effects of the digital divide are still very much present today,” Peltz said. “There needs to be a basic level in which people and populations can access a digital medium in order to engage.”

Even if households have the proper internet infrastructure to access telehealth appointments, those who aren’t digitally literate — often seniors — don’t have the understanding to create a virtual appointment.

The report suggests health plans automatically conduct universal screenings for members that might need digital assistance. By helping them navigate the seemingly byzantine process, providers can close the digital divide and “facilitate more equitable telehealth access and support social, educational and economic advancement.”

Peltz said telehealth’s expansion provides patients with an opportunity to find a provider tailored to their needs by opening up access to providers outside of their area. But minority communities have long recounted their inability to find someone who can empathize with their situation in ways white providers cannot.

“There are a lot of challenges in finding a therapist or a mental health provider — one that you identify with, have a strong therapeutic relationship,” Peltz said. “Telehealth has created new avenues for broadening that diversity of a provider network to meet that cultural need of a member, and how you no longer have to think as much geographically where that provider is located and maybe get access in other ways.”

An integral part of finding a provider is communication, creating another obstacle for those with language barriers — often communities of color.

Elias Chavez, a 26-year-old graduate student at Boston University, was a telehealth user before the pandemic. He used the online therapy platform “Talkspace” to speak with a licensed mental health professional and believes it yielded positive results.

But Chavez acknowledges that had English been his second language, getting those same results would likely have been much more difficult.

“(To get matched) you have to use highly specified language about mental health and mental well-being, and it gets a little confusing because certain words may not translate or they might use idioms,” Chavez said. “There would have been a lot of elements of guessing involved.”

Aside from accessibility and affordability, another key component to closing the telehealth disparity is lacking: awareness. Finding ways to address this is what Peltz calls the “million-dollar question.”

Patients — especially families with children — need adequate knowledge of the telehealth process. Peltz said the experience should be as person-centered and inclusive as possible, with shared decision making between providers and patients about what best suits them and their family’s needs.

“For a family that may have a lot of financial hardships to have to make those daily tradeoffs, like ‘Will this cost me more than I do in person? Do I take the bus there or do I need to pay for parking?’” Peltz said. “There’s a lot of personal preference around how and when to get care. I suspect if you were to ask me as a provider, you ask me as a researcher and then ask me as a parent, I might give you three separate answers.”

Lora Pellegrini, president and CEO of the Massachusetts Association of Health Plans, said the search for solutions is a work in progress.

“Our board is in a unique position to convene a public conversation and getting that reporting into the right hands,” Pellegrini explained. “Sharing it with elected officials and folks in the administration can help get the word out. There are opportunities to really leverage this information to make those important connections.”

Kana Ruhalter writes from the Boston University Statehouse Program.


Support Local Journalism

Subscribe to the Greenfield Recorder, keeping Franklin County informed since 1792.

Greenfield Recorder

14 Hope Street
Greenfield, MA 01302-1367
Phone: (413) 772-0261


Copyright © 2021 by Newspapers of Massachusetts, Inc.
Terms & Conditions - Privacy Policy