All Souls Church in Greenfield.
All Souls Church in Greenfield. Credit: STAFF PHOTO/PAUL FRANZ

GREENFIELD — Complete with historic photos and newspaper clippings, a tour of the All Souls Church was given to the public as part of its 125th anniversary on Thursday.

Chair of the All Souls Property Committee Russ Pirkot, of Greenfield, gave the tours on the exact date the All Souls Unitarian Universalist Church building, on the corner of Hope and Main streets, opened to the public.

The story of the opening was reported in The Gazette and Courier of Greenfield back on Saturday, Jan. 12, 1895, according to Pirkot.

With photos inside of the minister’s study, as well as archival scans on a laptop, Pirkot recounted a brief history of the church.

“The Third Congregational Society of Greenfield was started by 23 men who were members of the Second Congregational Church, who left because they couldn’t abide with the fire and brimstone,” Pirkot said.

The first meeting of the group was held in June 1825 on Bank Row, in the building now occupied by the Connecticut River Watershed Council and The Literacy Project, according to an informational handout from All Souls Church. Its first minister was the Rev. Winthrop Bailey, of Pelham.

The church was relocated to its current location at the corner of Main and Hope streets in August 1837, when a new wooden church was built for the cost of $2,250, according to the handout.

After other ministers provided services, the Rev. John Farwell Moors, who was previously a pastor in Deerfield, agreed to serve in Greenfield on the condition he could use the building.

“Then he was hired full-time here,” Pirkot said. “Shortly after, the Civil War started and Moors volunteered in Massachusetts’ volunteer infantry.”

According to the handout, attendance increased when Moors was in the pulpit.

After Moors returned, Pirkot said he stayed for 21 years and when he left, there was a push from his successor to expand the building.

“An architect from Boston, J. William Beals, designed a new church,” Pirkot said. “Rev. Arthur Anderson Brooks wanted a new building, one ‘better adapted to modern tastes and needs.’”

Pirkot said construction of the new building took seven months, and the old building was moved further down Hope Street, eventually becoming the offices of the Greenfield Recorder.

Some of those in attendance said while they knew some of the history of the church, they took something new away, too.

Board chair at All Souls Church, Kate Mason, of Greenfield, said she knows Pirkot put in a great effort to learn and gather information about the church’s history.

“What amazes me is how deep he dug into the information,” Mason said. “I remember reading one of the documents that said it wasn’t just a building, it was a family. That’s what keeps me coming — the family here.”

Jay Goldspinner, of Greenfield, said she came to the event because she is neighbors with Pirkot. She said she liked to see how the church fits into the community now versus the 1800s.

“I wanted to come and support him,” Goldspinner said. “I’ve had a long relationship with this church, off and on, and I’ve seen it through phases. … I preached here four times. I’m a storyteller and I’m interested in the story here. I found it fascinating when they moved the old building back. I wonder how they did it; maybe they used rollers of some sort.”

Kirsten Levitt, executive chef and executive director of Stone Soup Café within All Souls Church, said she’s proud to be a member of the church and its wider community.

“The many services that All Souls provides us with are an example of how to be a community, a good neighbor, a home of worship and wonder, a place of deep compassion and care for all of us,” Levitt wrote in an email Thursday.

Levitt recounted how the Franklin County Community Meals Program started at All Souls before becoming a separate entity, and how the Stone Soup Café has offered its meals and programming at All Souls since 2011. Additionally, the Social Justice Committee will host its 18th annual Anti-Racism Film Festival there in May, and as of November 2019, the Poor People’s Campaign of Franklin County meets every other week in the sanctuary.

She added that the church has survived ups and downs, but has continued to “push forward into the future.”

“This church is like the determined ‘Little engine that could,’” Levitt said. “A small group of determined people perpetually thinking and hoping that they can make a difference in our community, city and even the world.”

Reach Melina Bourdeau at mbourdeau@recorder.com or 413-772-0261, ext. 263.